Service of the Living Tradition Day: GA 2010 Day 2

Ok, I will admit I think of each day of General Assembly in relation to the major events of that day… and yesterday was, to my mind, Service of the Living Tradition Day. It was not only Service of the Living Tradition Day, but my Preliminary Fellowship Service of the Living Tradition Day.

One of the things that amazes me about GA is how things get discussed in real-time… how what might have been a month long discussion through email and the minister’s chat list-serve becomes an intense and interpersonal conversation. I think that having such conversations at GA that gives us the ability to have those conversations later through electronic media. On the first day, it was people who wanted to talk with me about the change in commanders for the Afghanistan War. In the morning at GA, that conversation (in my experience) focused at first on the opening ceremony chalice lighting, and then quickly moved on to the CSAI on Peacemaking.

I have made a commitment this GA not to plan on attending a whole bunch of workshops. Usually, I set up a strategic plan, and I have run from workshop to workshop. This year, I have some meetings and appointments that are outside the GA Schedule (lunch with colleagues, a conversation with the new CLF Minister, baby-shower for a mentor, etc.) I will be at most of the plenary sessions. But overall my plan is to just be, and when I have a time when there is no where else to be, I wander into a workshop or two.

So, much of my GA (besides plenarys) I’m wandering the hallways talking to friends and colleagues. Joyous!

I did attend the UU Christian Fellowship Communion Service, and I felt sad… Sad that one of the few places I get to attend communion that is open and welcoming is at GA.  In some of my myriad of minsiterial roles I offer communion to others, but GA (and perhaps the UUCF Revival) are some of the few places where I simply get to accept communion in the open and affirming way of Unitarian and Universalist Christianity. Rev. Alma Crawford preached a high energy and wonderful sermon, but I was there for this moment of connection represented in bread and wine. 

Attending a UUCF service also reminds me that, as a Christian Deist, there are places of theological contention for me even with some UU Christian colleagues, in particular to one reference to the resurrected Jesus… but such diversity of theological thought is part of the beauty of coming together into our liberal faith communities.  I don’t accept the truth of a resurrected Jesus, and yet here I can still take communion.

Last night was one of those events that I “had” to be at… the Service of the Living Tradition is a whole different experience when you are sitting on the stage. Reading the lines to the hymns backward from the backside of the screen is a skill I have not yet acquired. I enjoyed the sermon… but it did highlight an old adage a minister once told me… “You know you’re a preacher when it’s really hard to listen to someone else’s sermon without thinking how you would have preached it”. So, as always when I’m in worship, I had two sermons happening… and it is an amazing moment when I am truly pulled out of my internal sermon and engaged in someone else’s.

Rev. Paige Getty had me as soon as she said “The Velveteen Rabbit”. Using, in my opinion, the second best Children’s story for adults to read, was genius. It was a metaphor for ministerial formation I had encountered before, and a reminder of what the many years of moving into ministry have been like.

It was also the last time I will ever wear my robe in public without a stole, thereby imitating a circuit court judge… that’s enough to celebrate all on its own.

I also want to celebrate all the members of the Unitarian Church of Evanston, who all sat together next to the line of recession so that they could cheer loudly when I recessed by… you all are in my heart. And thank you for not cheering during the actual ceremony!

I did not get to stay for Peter Mayer’s concert… It would have been wonderful, and I love Peter Mayer… I would love to hear about how it was from those of you who were there.

All in all, day 2 of GA began for me with Peacemaking, continued with meeting, greeting, and re-connecting, and finished with processing and recessing. Day three… or as I know it Bridging Day… begins again. We begin again in love.

Yours in Faith,

Rev. David

Opening Day: GA 2010 Day 1

It is always amazing to me, that first day of General Assembly. I seem to spend most of that first day in the hallways, greeting friends not seen in awhile. Those who have been there awhile point others in the right direction to get to the myriad of events and places to check in, and we stand in the hallway, greeting one another.

Two things were different this year… the first was all the congratulations from colleagues and friends, on my ordination and graduation. Others wanted to know my plans for next year, and still others came by to share with me theirs. So much of our faith is about that “meeting” – the relational dynamic that is one of the core elements of this faith we call Unitarian Universalism.

At this General Assembly which has the potential to be quite contentious, we need to be reminded of the importance of the relational dynamic in our Liberal Faith.

I attended a dinner for Military Chaplains and Chaplain Candidates, where we were able to share our love for and say goodbye to Rev. Beth Miller, the outgoing Director of Ministry and Professional Leadership of the UUA, and more importantly to us, the UUA Military Chaplain Endorser. Never have we UU Military Ministers had such an amazing advocate and friend, always willing to make time in her busy schedule for one of “her” ministers. We visited with one another, shouted some inter-service rivalry across the room, and said some hello’s and goodbyes. It was wonderful to see all my military chaplain colleagues.

I then briefly attended the CMWD / Heartland ingathering… and then switched into my dress uniform for the opening ceremonies. If you want to be noticed at General Assembly, wear a U.S. Army Class A Uniform. Any friends and colleagues who had not found me before found me then… I was also amazed at how many people I did not know wanted to come up and shake the hand of one of our faith’s military chaplains, and do the UU version of “Thank you for your service” (the UU version is often much longer).

What shocked me was when the denizens of the Celestial Lands began to find me and tell me how much they loved the blog and website… I write Celestial Lands for myself… and it never fully sinks in as real that others read it, until someone comes up to you at GA with a whole collection of their favorite articles printed off, looking for a signature. Amazing… and thank you.

I loved the banner parade, especially seeing banners of congregations I have preached at, have served, or will be serving soon (yes, I saw the Midland banner). Seeing Peter Mayer perform live was wonderful, as was all of the music. The Chalice Lighting raised a few Freudian eyebrows… and I have yet to decide if the innuendo’s within the reading were intentional or not… a mystery for the ages.

But above all else, the Opening Ceremony of GA serves one purpose… to remind us that our Liberal Faith Movement is more than just our one church, or our small cluster of churches. It shows us that we are not as isolated as we sometimes feel, or as we sometimes make ourselves seem. It reminds us we are a faith with a vital, necessary, and noble purpose… no less than the salvation of the world, in this time, in this place, for us all.

And, as one colleague invited me to an after-party, another colleague said “No, David will go back to his hotel room and get some sleep… he’s the responsible one.” As I was beginning to feel good about that, another said “No, it’s just that he’s married”. Also true.

And so begins the 2010 General Assembly of the UUA.

Yours in faith,

Rev. David

Moving out of Liminality, and Into New Ministries

A few weeks ago I wrote an article exploring what it felt like to inhabit a space of liminality, or to put it another way, to hold my life in an intentional space of creative not-knowing, allowing possibilities and dreams to burble with hopes and visions. That space has allowed me to explore many possibilities for the coming years, to enter into conversations with several different congregations, to explore some civilian Chaplaincy ministries, and to even look at a few possibilities that seem “off the wall” and imagine what my ministry would look like if I were to go in a totally unexpected tangent…

During an exercise last week I was asked to pick a picture from a book and then explain why that particular picture represented my internal landscape. I seized on a picture of a glacier, with sharp angles and profound clarity… and I knew in that moment that I had moved out of my time of liminality, and into a time of increased clarity. My internal reality had shifted from one of intentional doubt and creative not-knowing, to one of mission, calling, and purpose. And yet, even with that newfound clarity, I am a deeper and broader person than I was just a few weeks ago, because of all of those who entered into creative conversation with me about what was possible. You know who you are, and I will not name you… rather just to say “Thank You” for being with me in this time of discovery.

A time of Liminality, or creative not-knowing, is more than just a time where you allow for many possibilities and perspectives, but one where you are intentionally seeing if one or two of those possibilities or perspectives can rise to the forefront on their own… can stand out from the background of all of the others. And among those possibilities and perspectives, can you make a choice between them as to where you are called to go? In my case, moving through this time of liminality, that is exactly what happened.

Sandy and I are excited that next August we will be moving to Midland Michigan, where I will be serving a one-year term as the Interim / Consulting Minister for the Unitarian Universalist Fellowship of Midland, Michigan. In my conversations with them, it became clear to me, through the intentional fuzzyness of my liminality, that this was the right place for my ministry in the coming year. I look forward to learning from them, being with them in their joys and sorrows, and exploring with them the boundaries of what is possible, as they are in search for a settled minister. I also look forward to spending a year in the Heartland District, where I have many colleagues, friends, and connections.

And, both Sandy and I look forward to getting out of Chicago. We really do! Horray!

Also, as I will only be walking with the UU Fellowship of Midland for a year, we have decided to accept the U.S. Army’s offer that I commission and accession as a U.S. Army Reserve Chaplain. I will be serving a reserve unit (1 weekend a month, 2 weeks a year) in the area of Northern Michigan. At the end of this year in Midland, our intent (at this time) is to look at a deployment to Afghanistan or Iraq (or wherever else our military happens to be by then).

However, going to Midland is not only a wonderful opportunity for ministry with a dynamic and growing congregation, but it also allows for me to extend at least part of this liminality on my future ministry for that year, and continue to explore options. Who knows what will come of that? Perhaps we will explore a search for a settled ministry, or a civilian chaplaincy somewhere. Perhaps the Fellowship in Midland and I can explore some of where each of us is called in the future together.

To all the colleagues who have offered advice, hope, and support through this time, thank you. And to anyone else looking to experience a time of liminality in their life or call, I wish you well. It has been an incredible experience for me, doubting soul though I was. Sorry, I could not resist the pun…

Yours in faith,

Rev. David

The Liminal Space of Intentional Not-Knowing

“I’ll miss the sea, but a person needs new experiences. They jar something, deep inside, allowing us to grow. Without change, something sleeps inside us, and seldom awakens. The sleeper must awaken!”

– The character of Duke Leto Atredies, in David Lynch’s movie interpretation of Frank Herbert’s novel, Dune.

The past month has been a time of profound change for me. That change has touched many areas of who I am, my professional identity… my personal identity. That change has affected the planning my wife and I have done about what the next few years of our lives would look like. It has affected how others have planned their lives in relation to ours, and how others seat me in their own identities. For some, who I am has shifted… for others, who I am in their personal cosmos has been reinforced.

As soon as I took off my robe and stole after my ordination, my sister walked up and punched me in the shoulder, just as she has done for decades. No matter what, she was stating that my place in her personal cosmos would always be the older brother that she would give a bruised upper arm to, just like when I was 12 and she 9. It is good to know, in a time of change and transition, that some things never change.

For years, my practice when I came to a time of such radical transition and change was formed, I believe, by my past in a conservative religious tradition. It was reinforced by an old military dictum that I encountered when I was an Army Sergeant… that often a bad plan is better than no plan at all. My practice when faced with a time when my plans were not going to happen the way I expected was to simply and immediately find a new plan. My practice when faced with a shift in my internal or external identity was to quickly build a new identity, and then defend it.

In this most recent experience, both my plans for the future and my own personal identity were thrown into question, by the decision of the U.S. Army for staffing reasons to offer to make me a full Army Chaplain, but in the Reserves or the National Guard, not on active duty. This came amidst other more planned transitions in my personal and professional identity… my graduation from seminary, my ordination into the UU ministry. I thought that my accessioning as an Active Duty Army Chaplain would be a seamless part of this transition in identity, but that turned out not to be the case. The seamless part, at any rate.

Now, in the past, faced with such a shift in my identity, my expectations, and my future plans, I would have just found another plan, no matter how bad it might be, and stuck with it. A bad or less considered plan is better than no plan at all, right? In truth, I began to do this… by sending an initial email to the Army that stated my intent was not to accept the commission at all, and commit myself to civilian ministry.

What shifted me away from adopting a new plan and path immediately was the idea of living in a “liminal space”. Before I encountered this term “liminal” I had been defining it for myself as “creative not-knowing”. In theological work, creative not-knowing is the commitment to doubt that allows one to begin thinking creatively about ideas such as the nature of God, of reality, and of our place in it. What struck me was that the idea of creative not-knowing I was learning to apply to theological exploration could also be applied to this space in my life, if I was willing to inhabit a space of liminality for a time.

Wikipedia defines liminality as “a psychological, neurological, or metaphysical subjective, conscious state of being on the “threshold” of or between two different existential planes… The liminal state is characterized by ambiguity, openness, and indeterminacy. One’s sense of identity dissolves to some extent, bringing about disorientation. Liminality is a period of transition where normal limits to thought, self-understanding, and behavior are relaxed – a situation which can lead to new perspectives.”

That is a pretty good description of the spiritual and mental space I have been inhabiting this last month, and still remain in to some extent. I have, very intentionally, chosen to stay in this place of change, and allow time for those many “somethings” to be jarred, deep inside, allowing for me to grow. I have explored many possibilities, and continue to explore several. I have invited others into that exploration. It has been amazing to witness how my friends and colleagues have reacted to me inhabiting some intentional liminal space… I think I’m learning as much about others as I am about myself.

Not that liminal space is a comfortable place for me to be… far from it. It has been exhausting, at times excruciating, and even a bit enveloping. An intentional practice of doubt is one thing when working with ultimate questions, values, and esoterical concepts… it is quite another when it involves how you are going to put food on the table in the coming year. And yet, the past month has been one of the most spiritually and personally creative times in my life, and it has been professionally transformative. I’m not going to speak about what all that entails right now, as my liminal space is still on-going… but I will say that I have been able to imagine and dream, hope and pray, craft and cultivate… and what may come out the other end of this liminal space has the potential to be so much more than if I had just immediately found a new plan and invested my identity and self into it.

It has also given me a new perspective upon this faith we call Unitarian Universalism … a new lens. Now, I don’t believe that any perspective or lens on our liberal faith movement contains all of who we are or is the key that unlocks a full understanding our shared faith… but this one is inspiring some new thoughts. Are we a faith that is located within liminality? Does our lack of certainty in belief, or in a plan for our future allow us to occupy a place of creativity that few other religious faiths touch? Could it be that how hard it has been (and how amazing) for me to stay in my personal liminal space shed light on why many people encounter Unitarian Universalism for a few years, but do not stay?

I do not know the answer to any of these questions… and that’s kinda the point to liminality, isn’t it? Not-knowing, I can ask the questions and experience the possibilities in a deeper way than if I could answer them. Perhaps we need a little liminality in order to be open to the sacred…

Yours in Faith,

Rev. David

Ordained, and Thank You…

I want to thank everyone who worked to make my ordination an incredible event… Everyone who participated in the service, everyone who worked to make the reception such a wonderful success, everyone who came and shared the fellowship with us. I specifically want to thank Chaplain Lt. the Rev. Cynthia Kane for an incredible sermon… it was a testimony to ministry, and the challenge and call of the prophetic ministry in-between communities.

I want to thank Rev. Barbara Pescan and Rev. Connie Grant for their hospitality and each for the Charge to the minister and the Welcome from the congregation respectively. Barbara, you made me cry… and Connie, you surprised me in a wonderful way with the poem by my mom.

I want to thank Rev. Lisa Presley for her Charge to the Congregation, requiring the congregation to remember me, even when I am gone… and Rev. John Tolley for the reminder of prayer within silence… and Rev. James Hobart for calling attention to the costs of seminary in the offertory… and Rev. Ian Evison for the reminder of why the Fellowship of ministry is so important in times of crisis, with the Hand of Fellowship… and Rev. Lori Hlaban for her prayer before we processed, and keeping us all together and in order… and so much of my journey to and through ministry has been through the doors and the counsel of the Rev. Nan Hobart, that no one else could have brought us the invocation.

I want to thank Chaplain Anne Edison-Albright, Chaplain Johnny Gillespie, and Chaplain Jeremy Wright for their readings from Christian Scriptures… and for being willing to be in a UU Ordination Service. I want to thank Chaplain Greg DuBow for his amazing reading of Ralph Waldo Emerson.

I also want to thank Steve Serikaku, the UCE Board of Trustees President for facilitating the Act of Ordination, and Carol Nielson for the absolutely beautiful stole (it’s perfect!). Also, credit goes to Bart Bradfield and the UCE Choir (and that wonderful band) for the beautiful and life-filled music! To the Internship committee who Invested me, and the Ordination Committee for making it all happen, my heart is touched by you all.

To all of those who worked stuffing envelopes, setting out food, cutting the cakes, and all the other items that went into making this service an incredible event, my deep appreciation. For all the gifts, I give my deepest appreciation and thanks. For all those who sent cards and letters, you were with us in spirit. To all those who attended, and all those ministerial colleagues who came from many different traditions and many different places to be with us, I am humbled. And… to Trudi Westwood… who worked tirelessly and with great patience with me to bring this event together… you are forever in my heart, and I thank you.

And last, but definitely not least… to the Unitarian Church of Evanston Illinois… thank you for ordaining me to the Unitarian Universalist Ministry!

You can see some photos of the event here.

Yours in faith

The Reverend David Glenn Pyle…

Rev. David

Long Robes and Titles – Reflection Upon my Upcoming Ordination

(38) As he taught, he said, “Beware of the scribes, who like to walk around in long robes, and to be greeted with respect in the marketplaces, (39) and to have the best seats in the synagogues and places of honor at banquets! (40) They devour widows’ houses and for the sake of appearance say long prayers. They will receive the greater condemnation. (Mark 12:38-40).

Many of you may know that this weekend, I will be ordained as a Unitarian Universalist Minister by the Unitarian Church of Evanston, IL. The church has worked hard to make this a wonderful event. My family is flying/driving in from the southern states, friends are coming in from across the country. Chaplain Lt. the Rev. Cynthia Kane, our liberal faith movement’s senior military chaplain is coming in from Maine to preach the ordination sermon. Some of the ministers that have meant so much to me in this journey into ordained UU ministry are participating in the service: Rev. Barbara Pescan, Rev. John Tolley, Rev’s. Jim and Nan Hobart, Rev. Lisa Presley, Rev. Ian Evison, Rev. Connie Grant and many others. Many of my clergy colleagues from many different religious traditions will be present to witness my formal entry into ordained ministry.

It has been a long journey since that day in 2004 in Galveston that I first thought of becoming a UU minister. I am a very different person now than I was then, and now realize how different I am each day because of the experiences of life and ministry. Yet through all of this preparation and anticipation, the above verse from the Gospel of Mark has stayed with me. “Beware of the scribes, who like to walk around in long robes…”

Now, I rarely wear my robe, and then only for as long as I have to. Those who have been with me in a worship service know I preach in a suit, and that’s not ever likely to change. But there is a greater message in this particular scripture that has been resonating with me, and it is not about the robe, but about the title that goes with it… what does it mean to be a “Reverend”? Why does our liberal faith movement, with our stated emphasis on the worth and dignity of every person, still grant such an honorific to someone as a way to “set them apart?”

As I have reflected on the purpose of the title Reverend, and all the long-robed trappings that go with it, I have come to the conclusion that the audience for that title is not the world at large, but the minister themselves. We do not call someone “Rev. so and so” to tell the rest of the world how important we think they are, or how pious or moral or just. Spend enough time among ministers and you will learn that ministers are just as human as everyone else… often moreso. The first time I had to get in-between two ministers on a soccer field as they looked like they were getting ready to throw punches at one another, it was underscored for me that, though we often do a good job at appearing more wise or peaceful or just, under it all we are still just human beings… perhaps just a little more self-aware than others. Not always… but sometimes.

No, I’ve realized that the purpose of my being called “Reverend” next Sunday is not to tell the world how wonderful/sacred/wise/ divine I am. It is to remind me, each and every time someone uses that title, of how much faith, trust, and responsibility I have accepted in becoming a minister. I am reminded that with the pastoral authority I have been granted comes a great responsibility.

We ministers are invited into people’s lives in some of the most intimate ways. We are trusted with what people hold sacred, with their deepest beliefs and their deepest pains. We are looked up to as models in a world that lacks them. We are invited to be with families in their most difficult decisions. We are trusted to help them find meaning in the most important events of their lives. We are witness to the best that is within people, and to the worst. We are there when they celebrate their births, their joining, and their deaths. We are who they turn to with that most sacred of questions… why?

We need to be reminded of the responsibility we carry, at every chance we can get. We need someone to say to us, “I have trusted you enough to place my heart in your hands, be careful what you do with it.” We need to be reminded that we are not social workers, we are not therapists, we are not doctors. As ministers, we invite people into relationship where they lower their boundaries and guards, trusting that we will not hurt them. We need to be reminded of that responsibility every time we put on the mantel of ministry… and I have decided that, for me, that is the meaning of the title “Reverend”. At it’s best, Reverend means “I have placed faith, hope, and love in my relationship with you, and I have trusted you. Respect that trust.”

I will, to the best of my ability… and I am humbled.

Yours in faith,

David

My Friend, Grief

I have come to the belief that what makes our culture so afraid of grief is that we often have buried within us layer upon layer of losses, one piled on top of another, the way that sand piles up upon the ruins of ancient cities, gets packed down, and turns to dirt, clay, and stone. Soon, all that we see of those earlier losses and their associated grieving is the tips of the towers, the high places… yet the griefs are always there. Those losses form the foundation upon which we build new hopes… new relationships… new structures of job and passion, almost from scratch. In time, many of these become losses too, with their associated grief. Then more sand, more dirt, and more clay turns to stone, burying them.

Layer upon layer of grief and loss, upon which we continue to rebuild the foundations and structures of our lives. Like a village built upon an ancient city, we are always aware of the loss of what has come before, and yet we try not to think about it. I know that for me, it is all these past losses that are the source of the feeling of discomfort when I am faced with another person’s loss and grief. I know that what makes me want to run away from a person I see crying in a hospital room is not the power of their grief, but the power of my own grieving and loss buried within the layers of my life. Learning to be with my own grief is what keeps me with them, in that hospital room.

There are so many different kinds of losses that we grieve. We think of grieving those who have died, but I believe that many of the other losses of human life are as profound, if not more profound, even if they are more easily hidden by the layers of sand and clay. I have mourned the loss of many relationships, quite a few of which I thought would last forever at the time. I have mourned the loss of some, if thank God not all, of my dreams. I have mourned the loss of my identity numerous times, as my constructed sense of self fell short of the reality of the world I encountered. I have mourned the loss of plans, of hopes, and of visions for the future so many times it is hard to name them all. I mourned the day that my nearsighted vision made me realize I would never be an astronaut. I was twelve. I mourned the day I came home to find my apartment empty and my first wife gone. I was 23. I mourned the day I made the decision that the best thing I could do for a friend was to never speak to them again. I was 34. I mourned the day that my father died, and mourned more never knowing what he would think of the man I became.

I say mourned, but that is not true. I have also come to the realization about grief that we never cease mourning any of these losses. Grief is a chronic condition. When people talk about acceptance in grief theory they are not talking about an end to mourning, but rather acceptance that this grief is now part of the losses of our lives, integrated into the fabric of our being. I have accepted that I will never be an astronaut… and I mourn it regularly. Being with that loss has become a part of who I am, and I am with it by following every shuttle launch, regularly viewing the Hubble telescope images, and reading science fiction every night before I go to bed.

There is no end to grieving. Each time I hear someone say “you should be done with your grief by now” or “when are you going to get over this?” I just want to yell at them. We are never “done” with our grief. A poet once said that “We were made for both Joy and Woe”. It might have been better if the poet had said “We are made of both joy and woe”. The woe in our lives, the grief, the loss, the pain… this is much of who we are, who we have been, who we are becoming. To say “I am past my grief” is to claim being past myself.

I believe we are so afraid of the grieving of others because we have buried our own grief and loss deep within our own lives, hoping that there is truth to the myth of being “done” with grief. Hoping that there really is a process of making it through the nice neat little steps to the bliss of “acceptance” where we can go back to how things were before the loss. It is a myth that I know I wanted to believe, and tried to enact in my life for many years. Seeing someone else’s loss in the moment, we are viscerally reminded that we are not as “done” with our own grief as we like to think. I did not go to my father’s grave for over a decade because I thought I was “done” with that loss, done with that grief. The tears of a young girl at the loss of her mom showed me how wrong I was.

Unacknowledged, the grief over the loss of my father affected almost everything I did in my life. I was unaware how, in that grief, I tried to re-enact my parent’s relationship with someone who rightly realized that I did not see her as an authentic human being, just a part in this play I was unconsciously enacting. I did not see how the beliefs I held about politics and life were not something that came from my values and principles, but from a need to validate the beliefs and opinions of my father as a testimony to his life.

I did not begin to see these things until I was forced to face my grief, first over the loss of my father, and then through that lens to face how much of human life is made up of our losses and our grieving. It was not until I realized what a half-empty shell of a person I would be were it not for my grief and losses. It was not until I realized that most of the deep lessons I had learned about myself, about the world around me, and about my fellow human beings came not from my times of success and joy, but the times of loss, defeat, and death.

It is more than what “I” have learned, for without such grief and loss there is no “I”. I remember a science fiction series I once read, one that I did not understand until just this past year. I remember reading that series as one of the most depressing times in my life, and yet I could not put the series down.

In the series, the main character suffers a never ending series of losses. He (Nicholas Seafort) encounters a never-ending series of catastrophes in his life. I found myself reading thinking ‘nothing worse could possibly happen to him’, and then it does. Again I think, ‘nothing worse could possibly happen to him’ and then it does. Again and again for about six books, the main character suffers loss after loss, grief after grief. Even when something good seems to happen, you know it is just foreshadowing the loss that is to come.

Two things have puzzled me about this series of books over the years. The first was why, for my own sanity, I could not just quit reading. I tried to quit, I really did. My significant other at the time tried to hide the books from me as a form of intervention. Friends would come by to try and cheer me up, to ask what was wrong, and would not believe it was just a science fiction series (because it wasn’t).

The second thing that has puzzled me was why, through out all this tragedy I kept feeling a sense of hope, a sense of the future of the character of Nicholas Seafort. You think that if anyone suffered a tenth of the loss that Seafort did, they would just give up living. What was it about this character that made him so appealing to me? Why did I sense some hope, and even some connection with him… some aspiration to be like him? Why did the author of this amazingly depressing series of books put the word “Hope” in every title?

I realize now these two questions are really one, and the answer to both is that Nicholas Seafort had learned to make friends with his grief and loss. He never tried to “get over” his grief, he simply made those experiences a part of who he was. He never tried to forget his losses, he just allowed them to become the foundation of what he rebuilt. Nicholas Seafort never sought to find sand, dirt, and clay to bury his griefs and losses… and because of it each loss became a gift, a lesson, and a friend. A constant and faithful companion on his journey through what (for science fiction) is an amazing life.

I know it’s a fictional character… but fiction has long been a medium for seeing what is at times hard to see in real life. Nicholas Seafort did not need to excavate his grief and loss, because he never buried it. He was not afraid of being with the grief and loss of others, because he lived with his own every day. He built the structures of his life not above buried ruins, but among them. And I admired him for it. What made me feel so depressed through the months of reading that series was not his losses… but mine.

Through this year as a hospice chaplain, I have been learning to not only excavate some of my own buried griefs and losses, but to live among the ones I currently have. I have found the space to be with grieving families not in clinical detachment, but by letting the friend of my own grief guide me. I am not claiming to do this well, and I still struggle every day with the desire to bury my grief (be they old or more recent) and begin again on fresh ground. I struggle with the resistance toward forming new relationships with patients because of my fear of more losses… and my friend grief pats me on my shoulder, and reminds me that the losses will come no matter what I do. He reminds me that he will be there with me, that he will help me to understand the meanings of those losses in my life, and he will help me to use what remains from those losses to build new structures, new plans, new relationships, and new dreams… ones that build upon instead of erase my past.

It is good to have a friend.

Yours in Faith,

David

The Torch May Pass From Me

I first want to thank everyone for the well wishes that have been sent our way over the last week or so. I also want to thank all of the colleagues and friends in ministry that have offered support and advice to Sandy and I as we have worked with and been integrating a rather significant change in our understanding of our future. That future is still fluid, but it has settled down somewhat.

There is a wonderful acronym in the military “BLUF” or “Bottom Line Up Front”. I’ve had that acronym directed a lot at me from officials in the Chaplain Corps the last few days. It means that you put the final line of the memo up at the top, rather than trying to set the stage for some bad news. You get the core message out of the way and then give the details.

So, Bottom Line Up Front: I may not be becoming an Army Chaplain, at least not anytime in the near future. In fact, it looks like I may have to resign from the Army altogether.

The irony of this situation is that I could become an Army Chaplain, a fully accessioned Army Chaplain, anytime I wanted to. The Army has offered to make me an Army Chaplain… but only in the Reserves, not the Active Duty. At every step along this path, we’ve been planning to serve soldiers and their families in the Active Duty Chaplaincy. Chaplains and others have encouraged us in this belief, citing my preparation for ministry, my prior service experience, and the fact that I am from a minority faith tradition in the military as reasons why so many have thought I would be picked up for Active Duty.

I have been assured by senior military chaplains that this decision has far less to do with my qualifications, and more to do with the fact that the current Active Duty Chaplain Corps is over-strength, and the Reserves is under-strength (by a lot). I have been encouraged (and even had my faith challenged) to accept the Reserve commission. Once I was chided by a Chaplain for not showing enough faith in my hesitance to accept the commission (I did not reply that what faith I have is in God, not in the U.S. Army). I’ve been told that if I accept the Reserve Commission I can just “suck it up” for a few years and then apply for Active Duty again.

However… I cannot feed my family, pay back student loans, or even make my rent on what a Reserve U.S. Army Chaplain makes. And, I have long known that having the possibility of being deployed would make it very difficult for a Unitarian Universalist Congregation to call me as their minister. Seeing the competitive nature of Board Certified Chaplaincy, I can also now see how difficult it would be for a civilian employer (say a hospice) to hire a Chaplain who could be deployed.

So, accepting the Reserve Commission would not give me the resources to take care of myself or my family, and it would make it very difficult to find a civilian job.

So, I’m more than a little stuck.

As the U.S. Army is transferring the Reserves from a Strategic Force (call up in case of emergency) to an Operational Force (regular deployments as part of the Active Duty Missions) the idea that the reserves means “one weekend a month and two weeks a year” is a myth, and one that the civilian world has woken up to. While it is hard enough on servicemembers, it is even worse on families. How our nation is currently using / overusing / misusing our Reserve military forces is a Justice issue, one that is on almost no one’s radar.

It is on mine, because for this last week Sandy and I have been trying to put together some way to make it work… we’ve even talked about my going back to my college job of waiting tables to try and make it work. We’ve looked at our finances six ways to Sunday… I’ve contacted civilian chaplain employers, and I’ve even sent feelers (and more than feelers) out to a few congregations looking for part time ministry.

And we just cannot see a way to make it work… and accepting the responsibilities of a reserve military chaplain without knowing how to make it work for my family seems unethical, irresponsible, and immoral to me. This was where the conversation of “Just have faith” came into being. When I stated that such kind of faith was not necessarily my religious tradition, the individual who said it seemed shocked. Far more in liberal faith to realize that I am responsible for the decisions I make in my life and their ethical and moral ramifications.

Emotionally, this week has been a roller-coaster. This all happened for us amidst my graduating from Meadville Lombard with my Master’s of Divinity, and my receiving Preliminary Fellowship as a Unitarian Universalist Minister. The good thing about it happening during graduation weekend is that there was no shortage of ministerial colleagues and friends to listen and talk me through my shock, and help me begin my process of grieving. And the two events will be forever linked in my mind… my graduation and the possible end of my military career.

Now, if I have to resign my commission, it will be under honorable circumstances… and so I could re-apply for active duty anytime in the next 2.5 years (until I get too old). I’ll have one more try. In that time I might go serve a congregation, or I might do some clinical chaplaincy (and finish board certification). But who knows what happens once I begin those particular career paths. Beginning will make it harder to leave.

No matter what, I will seek ways to support and aid military families and returning veterans. It may just not be as I planned. Perhaps clinical chaplaincy will take me to the VA, or perhaps resigning my commission will allow me to speak to the many issues of Justice that I see happening within today’s military. Perhaps I might be able to support those UU’s who do make it into the military chaplaincy.

All I know is that, though the door is not closed, it appeared to me to be closing. My packet will be re-considered by the board for Active Duty in mid-June, so there is still another chance at Active Duty, but the standards of this board will be the same as the last one, so they are more than likely to reach the same decision.

This morning I went up to Great Lakes, and I saw how excited the recruits were to hear the message of Liberal Faith. “This is what I’ve been looking for my whole life!” one of them said excitedly after the service. That is something I’ve long known… how important our liberal faith is to the future of the military and to the lives of those young service members. Now I just have to realize that I may have carried the torch as far as I can, and have to pass it off to someone else.

Yours in faith,

David